Copernicus' "Commentariolus" summarized his heliocentric theory. It listed the "assumptions" upon which the theory was based as follows:
HP G42-364LA Laptop Keyboard
"1. There is no one center of all the celestial circles or spheres.
2. The center of the earth is not the center of the universe, but only of gravity and of the lunar sphere.
3. All the spheres revolve about the sun as their mid-point, and therefore the sun is the center of the universe.
TOSHIBA 9J.N7482.901 Laptop Keyboard
4. The ratio of the earth's distance from the sun to the height of the firmament (outermost celestial sphere containing the stars) is so much smaller than the ratio of the earth's radius to its distance from the sun that the distance from the earth to the sun is imperceptible in comparison with the height of the firmament.
TOSHIBA Satellite U305-S2804 Laptop Keyboard
5. Whatever motion appears in the firmament arises not from any motion of the firmament, but from the earth's motion. The earth together with its circumjacent elements performs a complete rotation on its fixed poles in a daily motion, while the firmament and highest heaven abide unchanged.
HP 597635-001 Laptop Keyboard
6. What appear to us as motions of the sun arise not from its motion but from the motion of the earth and our sphere, with which we revolve about the sun like any other planet. The earth has, then, more than one motion.
7. The apparent retrograde and direct motion of the planets arises not from their motion but from the earth's. The motion of the earth alone, therefore, suffices to explain so many apparent inequalities in the heavens."
Compaq Presario CQ57 Series Laptop Keyboard
De revolutionibus itself was divided into six parts, called "books":
[citation needed]
- General vision of the heliocentric theory, and a summarized exposition of his idea of the World
Mainly theoretical, presents the principles of spherical astronomy and a list of stars (as a basis for the arguments developed in the subsequent books)
DELL Vostro 1014 Laptop Keyboard
- Mainly dedicated to the apparent motions of the Sun and to related phenomena
- Description of the Moon and its orbital motions
- Exposition of the motions in longitude of the non-terrestrial planets
- Exposition of the motions in latitude of the non-terrestrial planets
Georg Joachim Rheticus could have been Copernicus' successor, but did not rise to the occasion.
[52] Lenovo 3000 N200 Laptop Keyboard
Erasmus Reinhold could have been his successor, but died prematurely.
[52] The first of the great successors was Tycho Brahe
[52] (though he did not think the earth orbited the sun), followed by Johannes Kepler,
[52] who had worked as Tycho's assistant in Prague.
[citation needed]
Despite the near universal acceptance today of the basic heliocentric idea (though not the epicycles or the circular orbits),
HP Pavilion zv6223ea Laptop Keyboard
Copernicus' theory was originally slow to catch on. Scholars hold that sixty years after the publication of
The Revolutions there were only around 15 astronomers espousing Copernicanism in all of Europe, "Thomas Digges and Thomas Hariot in England; Giordano Bruno and Galileo Galilei in Italy; Diego de Zuniga in Spain; Simon Stevin in the Low Countries;
Lenovo Thinkpad T520 Laptop Keyboard
and in Germany, the largest group – Georg Joachim Rheticus, Michael Maestlin, Christoph Rothmann (who may have later recanted),
[71] and Johannes Kepler."
[71] Additional possibilities are Englishman William Gilbert, along with Achilles Gasser, Georg Vogelin, Valentin Otto, and Tiedemann Giese.
[71] ACER Aspire 4736Z laptop keyboard
Arthur Koestler, in his popular book
The Sleepwalkers, asserted that Copernicus' book had not been widely read on its first publication.
[72] This claim was trenchantly criticised by Edward Rosen,
[f] and has been decisively disproved by Owen Gingerich, who examined every surviving copy of the first two editions and found copious marginal notes by their owners throughout many of them. Gingerich published his conclusions in 2004 in
The Book Nobody Read.
[73] HP Pavilion DV7t-3100 laptop keyboard
The intellectual climate of the time "remained dominated by Aristotelian philosophy and the corresponding Ptolemaic astronomy. At that time there was no reason to accept the Copernican theory, except for its mathematical simplicity [by avoiding using the equant in determining planetary positions]."
[74] HP Pavilion dv6-2150es laptop keyboard
Tycho Brahe's system ("that the earth is stationary, the sun revolves about the earth, and the other planets revolve about the sun")
[74] also directly competed with Copernicus'. It was only a half century later with the work of Kepler and Galileo that any substantial evidence defending Copernicanism appeared, starting "from the time when Galileo formulated the principle of inertia...
HP Pavilion dv6-3107ax laptop keyboard
[which] helped to explain why everything would not fall off the earth if it were in motion."
[74] It was not until "after Isaac Newton formulated the universal law of gravitation and the laws of mechanics [in his 1687
Principia], which unified terrestrial and celestial mechanics, was the heliocentric view generally accepted."
SONY VAIO VGN-FS415E laptop keyboard
Only mild controversy (and no fierce sermons) was the immediate result of the publication of Copernicus' book. At the Council of Trent neither Copernicus' theory nor calendar reform (which would later use tables deduced from Copernicus' calculations) were discussed.
[citation needed]
The first notable to move against Copernicanism was the Magister of the Holy Palace (i.e., the Catholic Church's chief censor),
HP Pavilion DV7-3165dx laptop keyboard
Dominican Bartolomeo Spina, who "expressed a desire to stamp out the Copernican doctrine".
[75][76] But with Spina's death in 1546, his cause fell to his friend, the well known theologian-astronomer, the Dominican Giovanni Maria Tolosani of the Convent of St. Mark in Florence. Tolosani had written a treatise on reforming the calendar (in which astronomy would play a large role),
SONY VAIO VGN-NW25GF laptop keyboard
and had attended the Fifth Lateran Council to discuss the matter. He had obtained a copy of
De Revolutionibus in 1544. His denouncement of Copernicanism appeared in an appendix to his work entitled
On the Truth of Sacred Scripture.
[77][78]
Emulating the rationalistic style of Thomas Aquinas, Tolosani sought to refute Copernicanism on philosophical arguments.
Compaq Presario CQ71-317EA laptop keyboard
While still invoking Christian Scripture and Tradition, Tolosani strove to show Copernicanism was absurd because it was unproven and unfounded on three main points. First Copernicus had assumed the motion of the Earth but offered no physical theory whereby one would deduce this motion. (No one realized that the investigation into Copernicanism would result in a rethinking of the entire field ofphysics.)
HP Pavilion dv6-2129ev laptop keyboard
Second Tolosani charged that Copernicus' thought process was backwards. He held that Copernicus had come up with his idea and then sought phenomena that would support it, rather than observing phenomena and deducing from that the idea of what caused it. In this Tolosani was linking Copernicus' mathematical equations with the practices of the Pythagoreans
FUJITSU Lifebook P1610 laptop keyboard
(whom Aristotle had made arguments against, which were later picked up by Thomas Aquinas). It was argued that mathematical numbers were a mere product of the intellect without any physical reality, and as such "numbers could not provide physical causes in the investigation of nature."
[75] (This was basically a denial of the possibility of mathematical physics.)
[citation needed] Packard Bell NEW90 laptop keyboard
Some astronomical hypotheses at the time (such as epicycles and eccentrics) were seen as mere mathematical devices to adjust calculations of where the heavenly bodies would appear, rather than an explanation of the cause of those motions. (As Copernicus still maintained the idea of perfectly spherical orbits he relied on epicycles).
SONY VAIO VGN-FS640/W laptop keyboard
This "saving the phenomena" was seen as proof that astronomy and mathematics could not be taken as a serious means to determine physical causes. Holding this view, Tolosani invoked it in his final critique of Copernicus, saying his biggest error was that he started with "inferior" fields of science to make pronouncements about "superior" fields.
HP 405963-001 laptop keyboard
Copernicus had used Mathematics and Astronomy to postulate about Physics and Cosmology, rather than beginning with the accepted principles of Physics and Cosmology to determine things about Astronomy and Math. In this way Copernicus seemed to be undermining the whole system of the philosophy of science at the time.
HP Pavilion G6-1223TX Laptop Keyboard
Tolosani held that Copernicus had just fallen into philosophical error because he hadn't been versed in physics and logic - anyone without such knowledge would make a poor astronomer and be unable to distinguish truth from falsehood. Because it had not meet the criteria for scientific truth set out by Thomas Aquinas, Tolosani held that Copernicanism could only be viewed as a wild unproven theory.
SONY VAIO VGN-FS315M Laptop Keyboard
Tolosani recognized that the
Ad Lectorem preface to Copernicus' book wasn't actually by him. Its thesis that astronomy as a whole would never be able to make truth claims was rejected by Tolosani, (though he still held that Copernicus' attempt to describe physical reality had been faulty), he found it ridiculous that
Ad Lectorem had been included in the book (unaware that Copernicus hadn't authorized its inclusion).
TOSHIBA Satellite C650-182 Laptop Keyboard
Tolosani wrote "By means of these words [of the
Ad Lectorem], the foolishness of this book's author is rebuked. For by a foolish effort he [Copernicus] tried to revive the weak Pythagorean opinion [that the element of fire was at the center of the Universe], long ago deservedly destroyed, since it is expressly contrary to human reason and also opposes holy writ.
SONY VGN-FE21H laptop keyboard
From this situation, there could easily arise disagreements between Catholic expositors of holy scripture and those who might wish to adhere obstinately to this false opinion. We have written this little work for the purpose of avoiding this scandal."
[78] Tolosani declared "Nicolaus Copernicus neither read nor understood the arguments of Aristotle the philosopher and Ptolemy the astronomer."
[78] HP G72-b60SF laptop keyboard
He wrote that Copernicus "is very deficient in the sciences of physics and logic. Moreover, it appears that he is unskilled with regard to [the interpretation of] holy scripture, since he contradicts several of its principles, not without danger of infidelity to himself and the readers of his book. ...his arguments have no force and can very easily be taken apart.
HP Mini 110-3180sv laptop keyboard
For it is stupid to contradict an opinion accepted by everyone over a very long time for the strongest reasons, unless the impugner uses more powerful and insoluble demonstrations and completely dissolves the opposed reasons. But he does not do this in the least."
[78] He declared that he had written against Copernicus "
LENOVO IdeaPad S10 20015 laptop keyboard
for the purpose of preserving the truth to the common advantage of the Holy Church."
[78] Despite the efforts Tolosani put into his work it remained unpublished and it "was likely shelved in the library of the Dominican order at San Marco in Florence, awaiting its use by some new prosecutor" (it is believed that Dominican Tommaso Caccini read it before delivering a sermon against Galileo in December 1613).
[78] HP Mini 110-3180sv laptop keyboard
It has been much debated why it was not until six decades after the publication of
De revolutionibus that the Catholic Church took any official action against it, even the efforts of Tolosani had gone unheeded. Proposed reasons have included the personality of Galileo Galilei and the availability of evidence such astelescope observations.
[ Lenovo ThinkPad Edge E125 laptop keyboard
How entwined the pre-Copernican theory was in theological circles can be seen in a sample of the works of John Calvin. In his
Commentary on Genesis he said that "We indeed are not ignorant that the circuit of the heavens is finite, and that the earth, like a little globe, is placed in the centre."
[79] HP Pavilion dv6-3230us laptop keyboard
Commenting on Job 26:7 Calvin wrote "It is true that Job specifically says 'the north,' and yet he is speaking about the whole heaven. And that is because the sky turns around upon the pole that is there. For, just as in the wheels of a chariot there is an axle that runs through the middle of them, and the wheels turn around the axle by reason of the holes that are in the middle of them, even so is it in the skies.
ACER K052030A1 laptop keyboard
This is manifestly seen; that is to say, those who are well acquainted with the course of the firmament see that the sky so turns."
[79] Calvin's commentaries on the Psalms also show a reliance on the pre-Copernican theory; for Psalms 93:1 "The heavens revolve daily, and, immense as is their fabric and inconceivable the rapidity of their revolutions,
DELL Inspiron 6400 Laptop Keyboard
we experience no concussion – no disturbance in the harmony of their motion. The sun, though varying its course every diurnal revolution, returns annually to the same point. The planets, in all their wanderings, maintain their respective positions. How could the earth hang suspended in the air were it not upheld by God's hand?
TOSHIBA NSK-TAJ01 Laptop Keyboard
By what means could it maintain itself unmoved, while the heavens above are in constant rapid motion, did not its Divine Maker fix and establish it."
[79] Commenting on Psalms 19:4 Calvin says "the firmament, by its own revolution draws with it all the fixed stars".
[79] There is no evidence that Calvin was aware of Copernicus,
ACER Aspire 7741G Laptop Keyboard
and claims that after quoting Psalm 93:1 he went on to say "Who will venture to place the authority of Copernicus above the Holy Spirit", have been discredited and shown to originate with Frederic William Farrar's
Bampton Lecture in 1885.
[79] Unlike Calvin many theologians did become aware of Copernicus' theory which became increasingly controversial.
[ ACER Aspire 7741G Laptop Keyboard
The sharpest point of conflict between Copernicus' theory and the Bible concerned the story of the Battle of Gibeon in the Book of Joshua where the Hebrew forces were winning but whose opponents were likely to escape once night fell. This is averted by Joshua's prayers causing the sun and the moon to stand still.Martin Luther once made a remark about Copernicus, although without mentioning his name.
SONY KFRMBA152B Laptop Keyboard
According to Anthony Lauterbach, while eating with Martin Luther the topic of Copernicus arose during dinner on 4 June 1539 (in the same year as professor George Joachim Rheticus of the local University had been granted leave to visit him). Luther is said to have remarked "So it goes now. Whoever wants to be clever must agree with nothing others esteem.
HP Pavilion dv6-3001so Laptop Keyboard
He must do something of his own. This is what
that fellow does who wishes to turn the whole of astronomy upside down. Even in these things that are thrown into disorder I believe the Holy Scriptures, for Joshua commanded the sun to stand still and not the earth."
[74] These remarks were made four years before the publication of
On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres and a year before Rheticus'
Narratio Prima.
HP HDX18-1100 CTO Laptop Keyboard
In John Aurifaber's account of the conversation Luther calls Copernicus "that fool" rather than "that fellow", this version is viewed by historians as less reliably sourced.
[74]
Luther's collaborator Philipp Melanchthon also took issue with Copernicanism. After receiving the first pages of
Narratio Prima from Rheticus himself, Melanchthon wrote to Mithobius (physician and mathematician Burkard Mithob of Feldkirch)
TOSHIBA Satellite C655-S9521D Laptop Keyboard
on 16 October 1541 condemning the theory and calling for it to be repressed by governmental force, writing "certain people believe it is a marvelous achievement to extol so crazy a thing, like that Polish astronomer who makes the earth move and the sun stand still. Really, wise governments ought to repress impudence of mind."
[80] HP G42-380LA Laptop Keyboard
It had appeared to Rheticus that Melanchton would understand the theory and would be open to it. This was because Melanchton had taught Ptolemaic astronomy and had even recommended his friend Rheticus to an appointment to the Deanship of the Faculty of Arts & Sciences at the University of Wittenberg after he had returned from studying with Copernicus.
[ GATEWAY NV-53 Laptop Keyboard
Rheticus' hopes were dashed when six years after the publication of
De Revolutionibus Melanchthon published his
Initia Doctrinae Physicae presenting three grounds to reject Copernicanism, these were "the evidence of the senses, the thousand-year consensus of men of science, and the authority of the Bible".
[81] HP 646568-001 Laptop Keyboard
Blasting the new theory Melanchthon wrote "Out of love for novelty or in order to make a show of their cleverness, some people have argued that the earth moves. They maintain that neither the eighth sphere nor the sun moves, whereas they attribute motion to the other celestial spheres, and also place the earth among the heavenly bodies. Nor were these jokes invented recently.
ACER Aspire One D150-1920 Laptop Keyboard
There is still extant Archimedes' book on
The sand-reckoner; in which he reports that Aristarchus of Samos propounded the paradox that the sun stands still and the earth revolves around the sun. Even though subtle experts institute many investigations for the sake of exercising their ingenuity, nevertheless public proclamation of absurd opinions is indecent and sets a harmful example."
[80] HP AEUT5U00010 Laptop Keyboard
Melanchthon went on to cite Bible passages and then declare "Encouraged by this divine evidence, let us cherish the truth and let us not permit ourselves to be alienated from it by the tricks of those who deem it an intellectual honor to introduce confusion into the arts."
[80] In the first edition of
Initia Doctrinae Physicae,
ACER Aspire One D150-1920 Laptop Keyboard
Melanchthon even questioned Copernicus' character claiming his motivation was "either from love of novelty or from desire to appear clever", these more personal attacks were largely removed by the second edition in 1550.
[81]
Another Protestant theologian who took issue with Copernicus was John Owen who declared that "the late hypothesis,
HP AEUT5U00010 Laptop Keyboard
fixing the sun as in the centre of the world' was 'built on fallible phenomena, and advanced by many arbitrary presumptions against evident testimonies of Scripture."
[82]
In Roman Catholic circles, German Jesuit Nicolaus Serarius was one of the first to write against Copernicus' theory as heretical, citing the Joshua passage, in a work published in 1609–1610, and again in a book in 1612.
[citation needed] APPLE A1278 Laptop Keyboard
In his 12 April 1615 letter to a Catholic defender of Copernicus, Paolo Antonio Foscarini, Catholic Cardinal Robert Bellarmine condemned Copernican theory, writing "...not only the Holy Fathers, but also the modern commentaries on Genesis, the Psalms, Ecclesiastes, and Joshua, you will find all agreeing in the literal interpretation that the sun is in heaven and turns around the earth with great speed,
ACER 9J.N0F82.A1D Laptop Keyboard
and that the earth is very far from heaven and sits motionless at the center of the world...Nor can one answer that this is not a matter of faith, since if it is not a matter of faith 'as regards the topic,' it is a matter of faith 'as regards the speaker': and so it would be heretical to say that Abraham did not have two children and Jacob twelve, as well as to say that Christ was not born of a virgin, because both are said by the Holy Spirit through the mouth of prophets and apostles."
[83] HP G72-b66US Laptop Keyboard
Perhaps the strongest opponent to Copernican theory was Francesco Ingoli, a Catholic priest. Ingoli wrote a January 1616 essay condemning Copernicanism as "philosophically untenable and theologically heretical."
[83] Though "it is not certain, it is probable that he was commissioned by the Inquisition to write an expert opinion on the controversy",
[83] ACER 9J.N0F82.A1D Laptop Keyboard
(after the Congregation of the Index's decree against Copernicanism on 5 March 1616 Ingoli was officially appointed its consultant). Two of Ingoli's theological issues with Copernicus' theory were "common Catholic beliefs not directly traceable to Scripture: the doctrine that hell is located at the center of Earth and is most distant from heaven;
HP G72-b66US Laptop Keyboard
and the explicit assertion that Earth is motionless in a hymn sung on Tuesdays as part of the Liturgy of the Hours of the Divine Office prayers regularly recited by priests."
[83] Ingoli also cited Genesis 1:14 where YHWH places "lights in the firmament of the heavens to divide the day from the night."
[83] Like previous commentators Ingoli pointed to the passages about the Battle of Gibeon and dismissed arguments that they should be taken metaphorically,
HP Mini 110-3180sv Laptop Keyboard
saying "Replies which assert that Scripture speaks according to our mode of understanding are not satisfactory: both because in explaining the Sacred Writings the rule is always to preserve the literal sense, when it is possible, as it is in this case; and also because all the [Church] Fathers unanimously take this passage to mean that the sun which was truly moving stopped at Joshua's request.
Lenovo 3000 N200 Laptop Keyboard
An interpretation which is contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers is condemned by the Council of Trent, Session IV, in the decree on the edition and use of the Sacred Books. Furthermore, although the Council speaks about matters of faith and morals, nevertheless it cannot be denied that the Holy Fathers would be displeased with an interpretation of Sacred Scriptures which is contrary to their common agreement."
[83] DELL Vostro 3450 Laptop Keyboard
In March 1616, in connection with the Galileo affair, the Roman Catholic Church's Congregation of the Index issued a decree suspending
De revolutionibus until it could be "corrected", on the grounds that the supposedly Pythagorean doctrine that the Earth moves and the Sun does not was "false and altogether opposed to Holy Scripture".
[84] DELL Vostro 3550 Laptop Keyboard
The same decree also prohibited any work that defended the mobility of the Earth or the immobility of the Sun, or that attempted to reconcile these assertions with scripture.
[citation needed]
On the orders of Pope Paul V, Cardinal Robert Bellarmine gave Galileo prior notice that the decree was about to be issued, and warned him that he could not "hold or defend" the Copernican doctrine.
[g] HP Pavilion dv6-2125ef laptop keyboard
The corrections to
De revolutionibus, which omitted or altered nine sentences, were issued four years later, in 1620.
[85]
In 1633 Galileo Galilei was convicted of grave suspicion of heresy for "following the position of Copernicus, which is contrary to the true sense and authority of Holy Scripture",
[86] and was placed under house arrest for the rest of his life
HP Pavilion dv6-2110ev laptop keyboard
At the instance of Roger Boscovich, the Catholic Church's 1758
Index of Prohibited Books omitted the general prohibition of works defending heliocentrism,
[87]but retained the specific prohibitions of the original uncensored versions of
De revolutionibus and Galileo's
Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems. Those prohibitions were finally dropped from the 1835
Index.
SONY VAIO VGN-N31Z/W laptop keyboard
There has been discussion of Copernicus' nationality and of whether, in fact, it is meaningful to ascribe to him a nationality in the modern sense.
Historian Michael Burleigh describes the nationality debate as a "totally insignificant battle" between German and Polish scholars during the interwar period.
[89] ACER TravelMate 6252 laptop keyboard
Polish astronomer Konrad Rudnicki calls the discussion a "fierce scholarly quarrel in ... times of nationalism" and describes Copernicus as an inhabitant of a German-speaking territory that belonged to Poland, himself being of mixed Polish-German extraction.
[90]
Poet Czesław Miłosz describes the debate as an "absurd" projection of a modern understanding of nationality onto Renaissance people, who identified with their home territories rather than with a nation.
[91] SONY VGN-FE11M laptop keyboard
Similarly, historian Norman Davies writes that Copernicus, as was common in his era, was "largely indifferent" to nationality, being a local patriot who considered himself "Prussian".
[92]
Miłosz and Davies both write that Copernicus had a German-language cultural background, while his working language was Latin in accord with the usage of the time.
[91][92] TOSHIBA Satellite L750-ST4NX1 laptop keyboard
Additionally, according to Davies, "there is ample evidence that he knew the Polish language".
[92] Davies concludes: "Taking everything into consideration, there is good reason to regard him both as a German and as a Pole: and yet, in the sense that modern nationalists understand it, he was neither."
[92] ASUS X53S laptop keyboard
Sheila Rabin, writing in the
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, describes Copernicus as a "child of a German family [who] was a subject of the Polish crown",
[3] while Martin Weissenbacher writes that Copernicus' father was a Germanized Pole.
[93] Encyclopædia Britannica,
[94] Encyclopedia Americana,
[95] TheColumbia Encyclopedia[96] Acer eMachines E640 laptop keyboard
The Oxford World Encyclopedia,
[97] and
World Book Encyclopedia[98] refer to Copernicus as a "Polish astronomer".
On 14 July 2009, the discoverers, from the Gesellschaft für Schwerionenforschung in Darmstadt, Germany, of chemical element112 (temporarily named ununbium) proposed to the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry that its permanent name be "copernicium" (symbol Cn).
TOSHIBA Satellite L655-S5107 laptop keyboard
"After we had named elements after our city and our state, we wanted to make a statement with a name that was known to everyone," said Hofmann. "We didn't want to select someone who was a German. We were looking world-wide."
[99] On the 537th anniversary of his birthday the official naming was released to the public.
HP Pavilion DV6z artist edition 2 laptop keyboard,
SONY VAIO VGN-N250E/B laptop keyboard,
HP Pavilion DV7-3067nr laptop keyboard
No comments:
Post a Comment